ASPN ActiveState Programmer Network
ActiveState
/ Home / Perl / PHP / Python / Tcl / XSLT /
/ Safari / My ASPN /
Cookbooks | Documentation | Mailing Lists | Modules | News Feeds | Products | User Groups


Recent Messages
List Archives
About the List
List Leaders
Subscription Options

View Subscriptions
Help

View by Topic
ActiveState
.NET Framework
Open Source
Perl
PHP
Python
Tcl
Web Services
XML & XSLT

View by Category
Database
General
SOAP
System Administration
Tools
User Interfaces
Web Programming
XML Programming


MyASPN >> Mail Archive >> boost
boost
[boost] Re: Re: [prereview request][fsm]
by Andreas Huber other posts by this author
May 28 2004 7:10AM messages near this date
[boost] Re: [prereview request][fsm] | [boost] Re: [prereview request][fsm]
E. Gladyshev wrote:
>  From: "Andreas Huber" <ah2003@[...].net>
>  [...]
> > Unfortunately, all FSM standards/publications I know are absolutely
> > silent on error handling.
> >
> 
>  I can understand why.
>  If you are referring to "error" as something unexpected,
>  then it is out of the state machine realm.

If the errors were unexpected it would make little sense to handle them in
the state machine, right?

>  The state machine mantra is complete behavioral determinism.
>  If "error" is an expected condition, then it is just a normal
>  event that is part of the state machine design.

When an entry action fails, you have the problem that the state machine is
unstable because it would be a bad idea to just continue to enter other
(inner) states (see Rationale). Since it is non-trivial to define what to do
in such a situation, I think it is unfortunate that all these standards are
silent on error handling. They implicitly force you define all your entry
and transition actions in a way so that they can never fail.

Regards,

Andreas


_______________________________________________
Unsubscribe & other changes: http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost
Thread:
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Darryl Green
Darryl Green
Darryl Green
Darryl Green
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
E. Gladyshev
Darryl Green
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Darryl Green
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Rob Stewart
Andreas Huber
Rob Stewart
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Darryl Green
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Rob Stewart
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Darryl Green
David Bergman
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Darryl Green
Andreas Huber
Robert Bell
David Abrahams
E. Gladyshev
Johan Nilsson
Jeff Flinn
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Jeff Flinn
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Iain K. Hanson
Robert Bell
David Abrahams
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David B. Held
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Johan Nilsson
Peter Dimov
Johan Nilsson
Topher Cooper
Johan Nilsson
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Robert Bell
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
E. Gladyshev
Rob Stewart
E. Gladyshev
E. Gladyshev
Rob Stewart
E. Gladyshev
Rob Stewart
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
E. Gladyshev
Marshall Clow
Marshall Clow
E. Gladyshev
David Abrahams
Darryl Green
E. Gladyshev
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Robert Bell
Darryl Green
Pavel Vozenilek
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
Gregory Colvin
Pavel Vozenilek
Andreas Huber
Robert Bell
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Johan Nilsson
Rob Stewart
Johan Nilsson
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Johan Nilsson
Rob Stewart
Kwee Heong Tan
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
John Fuller
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
Andreas Huber
Aleksey Gurtovoy
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
David Abrahams
Andreas Huber
David Abrahams
David Abrahams

Privacy Policy | Email Opt-out | Feedback | Syndication
© ActiveState Software Inc. All rights reserved